A Conservative MP has said there needs to be "acceptance of the law of the land" from Muslim communities above that of Sharia law.
John Howell (Henley) told MPs in a Westminster Hall debate on Sharia law courts in the UK, that British law should take primacy.
He added: "There needs to be acceptance of the law of the land as there is within other communities, and particularly within the Jewish community, where they do accept that British law overrides their own religious law."
The Tory backbencher said he was "well aware that the charge of Islamophobia may be levelled against us for raising this subject" adding: "It is right that Sharia law courts or councils are looked at in terms of their conformity with the European Convention on Human Rights just as other aspects of UK society are."
Mr Howell said he accepted that Sharia councils offer a form of alternative dispute resolution, with around 90% of their dealings in the UK looking at issues of divorce.
He added: "They are certainly fulfilling a need in some Muslim communities. There is a demand for religious divorce and this is currently being answered by the Sharia councils."
Labour MP Naz Shah (Bradford West) warned against "throwing the baby out with the bathwater".
She added: "The idea that is peddled in the right-wing media of Sharia courts replacing the British judiciary has no truth in it. The first law of Sharia is, the absolute tenet of it, is that the law of the land takes precedence.
"I really struggle with the idea that there needs to be acceptance of the law of the land. Muslims do accept the law of the land.
"The majority of Muslims in this country, as with any people of faith or non-faith, accept the law of this land."
Shadow solicitor general Nick Thomas-Symonds said there is a problem of "misinformation" in this area, and said there is "clearly not" any plan to introduce a parallel legal system in the UK.
Mr Thomas-Symonds said: "We have to be very wary of misinformation here, particularly in terms of this idea we see that Parliament is somehow introducing this parallel law, which is clearly not the case.
"I think it is incumbent on all of us to be making that clear and to be careful with the language that we use in this regard."
Justice minister Edward Argar said there is a place for Sharia law but said that, where there are conflicts with UK law, the law of the land "must, and will, always prevail".
Mr Argar said: "I would like to set out the Government's position on Sharia law. As the Prime Minister has said, and as members have mentioned today, there is one rule of law in the United Kingdom and, in practice, that means that within each of the UK jurisdictions, a single system of law, legislated according to our constitutional arrangements, this parliament and the devolved administrations."
Mr Argar said there needed to be clarity, and urged MPs and the media to be careful with the language they use. He pointed out there is no "parallel system of Sharia law" in the UK.
He said: "If there are any conflicts between religious practices and national law, national law must, and will, always prevail."
By George Ryan and Josh Thomas
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel